It can be difficult to manage a stubborn dog who is aggressive with people. This behavior is common in herding dogs such as the Border Collie or German Shepherd. A collar may be your best option if you don’t have the money to hire a professional trainer. It can be difficult to find the right collar for your dog, as there are so many brands.
So that you can compare the best training collars for stubborn dogs, we have decided to test out several brands. We will give you the pros and cons of each brand, as well as a buyer’s guide that will help you to make informed purchases.
These are the 7 Best Training Collars For Stubby Dogs
1.SportDOG WetlandHunter Remote – Best Overall
The SportDOG WetlandHunter425X Remote Training Dog Collar, our most popular training collar for stubborn dogs, is the SportDOG WetlandHunter425X. The collar has a 500-foot range, so you can easily control your dog on the trail. It also allows you to be ready for any mishaps. The device is waterproof up to 25 feet so it’s ideal for dogs who love to swim in the lake or river. You can adjust the stimulation level to suit your pet’s needs.
We enjoyed reviewing the SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X and were impressed by the camo finish. It was a bit pricey, especially if this is your first time using one of these tools and you aren’t certain if it will be able to do what you need.
Pros
- 500 feet range
- 21 levels of stimulation
- Waterproof up to 25 feet
- Tone and vibration options
- Camo finish
Cons
- Expensive
2.PetSafe Smart Dog Training Collar – Best Value
We choose the PetSafe Smart Dog Training Collar is our top pick for stubborn dogs. The collar has a 75-yard range and a rechargeable battery so it can always go. This device is great for training dogs and can be controlled with your smartphone using both the Android and iPhone operating systems.
PetSafe Smart Dog Training Collar has one problem. Although most people have a smartphone, not all of them do. The Bluetooth signal was weak and the collar didn’t work well because it requires you to unlock your phone in order to make adjustments.
Pros
- 75-yard range
- Rechargeable battery
- Waterproof
- Use your smartphone
Cons
- Bluetooth does not work well
3.SportHunter 825X – Premium Choice
The SportHunter825X is our top choice training collar for stubborn dogs. You can adjust the shock level to your dog’s needs. It has 21 levels of stimulation. The collar can be worn anywhere the dog is comfortable, including up to 1/2 mile. Once your dog understands what the collar is saying, you can switch to vibrating or toning. The collar is waterproof up to 25 feet, so your dog won’t have to worry about it getting in the water.
The SportHunter 825X was a great choice and we found it to be very effective. The only problem is the price. Other brands have an option that turns the color off automatically if the dog barks. This is to reduce stress and injury.
Pros
- 21 levels of stimulation
- Optional tone and vibration options
- Waterproof up to 25 feet
- Rechargeable batteries
Cons
- There is no automatic shutoff
- Expensive
4. Educator By E-Collar Technologies
The Educator by E-Collar Technologies can be used as a training collar for stubborn dogs. The collar is smaller and more discreet to make it easy to attach and take off. The transmitter and receiver are waterproof and can be used to train your dog even if you live a long distance. You can choose from 100 different stimulus levels to ensure your dog is trained safely. Video instructions will help you fully understand the features and how it works.
The downside of the Educator is its high price, which might make it prohibitively expensive for new pet owners. Although we had no problems with the transmitter, we felt it was fragile and could break if dropped.
Pros
- A smaller color is more discrete
- Receiver and transmitter that is waterproof
- Instructions in video
- 100 selectable stimulus levels
Cons
- Expensive
- Sender is fragile
5. High Tech Pet Products ET-1 Radio Dog Training Collar
Another electric collar is the High Tech Pet Products ET-1 Electronic Radio Dog Training Collar. It features an easy-to-use transmitter that lets you train up to three dogs simultaneously. To train more dogs, you will need to purchase additional colors. You can use positive and negative tones to train your dog if they are quick learners. We have had great success with them.
We found that the ET-1 from High Tech Pet Products didn’t have the half-mile range claimed. In fact, we frequently saw the transmitter intermittently working at shorter ranges. It also kills the battery within a matter of hours so make sure to keep it charged so it is ready for use when you need it.
Pros
- Negative and positive tones
- The transmitter is easy to use
- You can work with up to three dogs
- Distances up to 1/2 mile
Cons
- It didn’t go the whole half-mile.
- Battery dies quickly
6. Frisco Waterproof Rechargeable Dog Training Collar
The Frisco Waterproof Rechargeable Dog Training Collar has a large 3/4 mile range. This collar gives you greater control than you could see in many cases. The collar has 127 stimulation levels to ensure that you don’t overstimulate your dog. There’s also a safety feature that stops overstimulation. It has an LCD screen that makes adjustments faster and easier. There are also complete instructions.
The Frisco Manger’s long range can quickly drain the battery, so only short sessions are possible before you need to charge. It’s expensive and you may not be able to see your dog as far as possible with models that have a range of at least 1/2 mile.
Pros
- Distances of 3/4 mile
- 127 stimulation levels
- LCD Screen
Cons
- Loses charge quickly
- Expensive
7.Herm Sprenger Ultra-Plus Training Dog Prong Collar
This list includes the Herm Sprenger Extreme-Plus Training Dog Prong Collar. It is the only collar made of steel prongs. These collars have been proven to be very effective and affordable. This collar is a great option for large dogs or for situations when you don’t want to take any chance that your dog might be misbehaving. It is simple to put on and can be attached to a leash. This gives your dog a signal to stop pulling on the collar.
It is very effective but can be dangerous if misused.
Pros
- No power
- It’s affordable
- Time tested
Cons
- Dogs can be injured
- It is easy to get carried away.
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Collar
Steel Prong vs Electric Shock Collar
The steel prong can cause harm to your pet. This could affect its behavior towards you and the collar and, in turn, change the way it behaves towards you. To get your dog to behave properly, we recommend that you use these devices very sparingly and only when absolutely necessary. You can start with the electric shock.
Many of these devices offer a variety of levels so that your dog doesn’t feel to painful. These devices can be used from far away, so your dog will feel that you are there. Large dogs may not be affected by electric shocks from most brands. The steel prong works well for them. Attach your leash to a pronged collar so that your dog knows who is responsible. You can also adjust the force you pull on the collar.
These collars should be used with caution. Talk to your vet for more information on how to make behavioral changes without causing harm to your dog.
Collar Range
Many brands will discuss the range of their electric collars. Although it might be convenient to have your dog controlled from miles away, it is not practical to give electric shocks to animals you cannot see. Any brand that promises more than 1/2 mile range should be avoided.
Weatherproofing Collar
We noticed many brands that do not offer waterproof when we were searching for brands to review. Many dogs love to swim in the water, and if you’re a dog owner for a while you will know this. Colors that aren’t waterproof won’t last as they will be exposed to the elements and often get wet. While we tried to select waterproof brands for our reviews, we will also point out any that are not effective.
Conclusion: Best Collar For Stubborn Dog
Our pick is the best for stubborn dogs. The SportDOG 425X Remote Training Dog Collar is able to reach 500 feet and can be programmed with 21 levels of stimulation. This will allow you to give your dog the right amount of shock to make them behave differently. If you require a longer range, we recommend the premium option. The SportHunter offers many of the same features and a longer range, up to 1/2 mile.
It can be difficult to manage a stubborn dog who is aggressive with people. This behavior is common in herding dogs such as the Border Collie or German Shepherd. A collar may be your best option if you don’t have the money to hire a professional trainer. It can be difficult to find the right collar for your dog, as there are so many brands.
So that you can compare the best training collars for stubborn dogs, we have decided to test out several brands. We will give you the pros and cons of each brand, as well as a buyer’s guide that will help you to make informed purchases.
